(The Center Square) – The Seattle Firefighters’ Pension Board is suing over proposals from Mayor Katie Wilson and the city council that would draw on its reserves to reduce budget pressure moving forward.
The board filed suit against Seattle last week as Wilson and the council balance a $175 million shortfall ahead of 2027 with account transfers, reprioritizing spending and raising taxes and fees. That includes plans to consolidate an actuarial account that essentially acts as a reserve for the retirement benefits.
Phil Talmadge, a former state lawmaker and Supreme Court justice representing the plaintiff, wrote in a statement to The Center Square that the city lacks authority to do this without the board’s approval.
“We used to call what the Council is now doing when I was on the Senate Ways and Means Committee looking for state revenue a ‘light bulb snatch,"” Talmadge wrote in an email with their lawsuit attached.
He argued that control of the firefighter pension fund and the actuarial fund lies with the board, which opposes calls to consolidate it from Wilson and Councilmember Dan Strauss, the budget chair. He says the actuarial account was intended to create reserves to relieve the general fund of future obligations.
Wilson’s idea would consolidate roughly $25.7 million from the actuarial account into the pension fund, with about $10.1 million of that covering general fund pension obligations over 2027-28. This reduces the amount the general fund must contribute to the plan in the short term to help balance the budget.
Tara Lee, the mayor’s director of communications, acknowledged the lawsuit in an email to The Center Square and said the consolidation would help avoid additional cuts while still fully funding benefits.
“This helped mitigate the level of reductions necessary to present a balanced budget, not just next year but in the out years,” Lee said, despite Wilson’s hopes to increase spending in her first budget. “Without this change, additional reductions in the 2027-28 budget would have been necessary.”
Strauss separately proposed a budget amendment to reduce general fund contributions to the pension plan by an additional $10.9 million annually, or about $22 million in the 2027-28 budget. That is more than double what Wilson would draw in her consolidation plan to reduce pressure on the general fund.
Kenny Stuart, president of the Seattle Fire Fighters Union, confirmed Monday that he sent a letter on behalf of IAFF Local 27 to Wilson and the council on Thursday expressing opposition to the proposals.
He argued that Strauss is using the proposal to fund additional spending that the council proposed in various amendments to Wilson’s budget proposal. Council staff wrote in an email on Monday that his amendment package currently would add about $51.2 million in general fund spending if approved.
“We believe that it is fiscally irresponsible and just plain wrong to use dedicated pension reserves for non-pension purposes,” Stuart wrote, adding that many beneficiaries are now widows. “Seattle Fire Fighters never forget, and our city should never forget the promises made to those who served.”
Michael Duchemin, president of the Retired Fire Fighters of Washington, told The Center Square that pension and medical benefits aren’t being withheld or immediately reduced. His concern is whether the pension fund can survive future economic headwinds without an actuarial fund acting as a backup.
“The more relevant impact is the lack of future, proper funding of the pension fund,” Duchemin wrote in an email. “If the pension fund in the future is deemed to be inadequate to cover all expenditures (an actuary makes regular reports on the health of the pension fund), then benefits could be put at risk.”
The council acknowledged the lawsuit during a budget meeting last Friday between executive sessions.
Central staff warned the council that drawing on the actuarial fund to ease general fund pressure in the short term could require higher city contributions to support full pension benefits later on.
The lawsuit came up again Monday in another budget meeting ahead of a vote on adoption this Friday.
“I wish we had had more transparency earlier in the process, so we would know we weren’t here today trying to figure this out,” Councilmember Maritza Rivera said Monday before voting on Strauss’ proposal.
The 8-1 vote, with only Rivera in opposition, added Strauss’ plan to Wilson’s budget, but the officials still need to vote on final adoption for it to go through.
